background image
on Wi-Fi, all mobile services are available and function
the same way, requiring no behavioral change by the
subscriber. From a subscriber's perspective, they continue
receiving the same mobile services, and the services sound
better, run faster and cost less.
In comparison, VCC will not be able to deliver a seamless
end-user service experience. As a "dual-service" approach,
VCC presumes mobile handsets access a separate core
network when connected via Wi-Fi than when connected
to the outdoor macro network. By its very definition,
VCC will result in a different end-user service experience.
While there is effort underway to mask differences, the
method for supporting features as basic as supplementary
services is still undefined.
DEPLoYMEnT TIME, coST & coMPLExITY
Deployment time, cost and complexity is a critical factor
for operators evaluating approaches for delivery of a
new service. How significant are upfront capital costs?
How long will it take to deploy? What are the ongoing
operational costs? How disruptive will it be to the current
network and operations?
The UMA standard was created with this specific
requirement in mind. For example, in order to speed time
to service deployment, lower capital costs and reduce
overall network disruption, UMA was specified to leverage
existing, standard interfaces into core networks.
Adding UMA to a mobile network is a straightforward
exercise, akin to deploying additional BSCs or RNCs. As a
result, UMA solutions map well into existing operational
and billing systems and are operationally familiar to
network personnel.
On the contrary, implementing a VCC-based approach to
DMH services would be a major undertaking. In addition
to deploying the new VCC functional elements, operators
would need to deploy an IMS-based core voice network
(including necessary operational, billing and support
systems), as well as an interworked-WLAN solution to
provide IP access.
MATURITY AnD InDUSTRY SUPPoRT
In the
mobile industry, it is has been proven time and again
that standardization is required before operators can
successfully leverage any new technology. Only through
standardization can operators get a portfolio of compliant
handsets from the major suppliers, as well as interoperable
equipment from multiple infrastructure vendors.
UMA is a fully-defined 3GPP standard. Since its
completion of the formal standardization process in April
2005, UMA technology has been implemented into fully
compliant mainstream mobile handsets from leading
suppliers (i.e. Nokia, Motorola and Samsung). Nokia
(Kineto), Motorola (Kineto), Ericsson, Alcatel and
22
UMA ToDAY
SPRING 2007
TECHNOLOGY